Kuvera Resources Pte Ltd. v. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. [2023]

đź’ˇ
Kuvera Resources Pte Ltd. v.
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. [2023]
[2023] SGCA 28 [Singapore]

Type of Lawsuit: Beneficiary appealed judgment for Confirming Bank that had dishonoured complying documents citing its sanctions clause.

Parties:
• Seller - PT Borneo Guna Energi
• Buyer - Oilboy DMCC
• Trader - Kuvera Resources Pte Ltd.
• Issuer - unknown, based in Dubai
• Nominated Bank/Advising Bank/Confirming Bank - JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.

Underlying Transaction: for purchase of 35,000 metric tonnes of coal (± 10%) to resell to Buyer (the Sales Contract)

LC: two UCP600 letters of credit

Decision: The trial court ruled in favour of Confirming Bank. Beneficiary appealed. The Singapore Court of Appeal, Sundaresh Menon, Judith Prakash & Steven Chong, JJ., reversed.

Factual Summary:

As part of an underlying trade between PT Borneo Guna Energi (Seller), an Indonesian company, and Oilboy DMCC (Buyer), a Dubai, UAE company, Kuvera Resources Pte Ltd. (Trader), a trader of Indonesian coal based in Singapore, advanced funds to Seller for purchase of 35,000 metric tonnes of coal (± 10%) to resell to Buyer (the Sales Contract). Trader was party to the Sales Contract which required that the coal be delivered in two shipments and payment made by two letters of credit obtained by Buyer from “a major or international bank” and further confirmed by a bank in Singapore. Accordingly, Buyer/Applicant caused Issuer, based in Dubai, to issue two UCP600 letters of credit of favour of Trader/Beneficiary (hereinafter “Beneficiary”) with terms pursuant to draft LCs attached to the Sales Contract.

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Documentary Credit World.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.